Mr. Earnshaw in Wuthering Heights

Mr. Earnshaw, a central character in Emily Brontë‘s timeless novel Wuthering Heights, embodies the complex dynamics of Yorkshire’s rural gentry during the early 19th century. As the patriarch of the Earnshaw family, he oversees Wuthering Heights, a remote farmhouse on the moors that serves both as his home and as a symbol of his status. His character is marked by a mix of generosity and traditionalism, reflecting the culture of the time. Within the rugged and windswept landscape of Yorkshire, Mr. Earnshaw upholds the values and duties expected of a gentleman, navigating the specific cultural and social nuances of his era.

His decisions and relationships within the household set in motion much of the novel’s ensuing drama. The contrast between his fatherly kindness and his occasional bouts of sternness paints a picture of a man caught between his affections and the expectations of his status.

Mr. Earnshaw’s significance in the novel extends beyond his immediate family to include his adopted son, Heathcliff. His choice to bring the orphan into his home disrupts the family’s dynamic and societal norms, challenging the cultural expectations of inheritance and social mobility. This decision not only triggers a chain of events that profoundly affects the relationships between the characters but also serves as a catalyst for much of the novel’s conflict. The resulting tensions and complex interactions among the characters of Wuthering Heights are a testament to Brontë’s exploration of human emotion and class constraints..

Recommended: Read Wuthering Heights at PageVio

1. Mr. Earnshaw Character Analysis

Mr. Earnshaw is a central figure in Wuthering Heights, whose actions set the stage for the novel’s exploration of themes such as love, power, and revenge. His decisions crucially impact the lives of his biological children, Hindley and Catherine Earnshaw, as well as Heathcliff, whom he adopts.

Relationship with Heathcliff

Mr. Earnshaw’s relationship with Heathcliff begins when he brings the orphan home from a trip to Liverpool, taking him into the Earnshaw family. His kindness to Heathcliff is evident, displaying a fondness that, while significant, is not explicitly portrayed as surpassing his affection for his son, Hindley. This preferential treatment creates tension within the family and establishes a cornerstone for future conflict. The fatherly love he shows Heathcliff contrasts sharply with Hindley’s cruelty towards him, drawing a divide between the characters.

Family Dynamics and Conflict

The decision to adopt Heathcliff disrupts the Earnshaw family dynamics, inciting jealousy and conflict. Hindley particularly resents Heathcliff, feeling usurped by the interloper. Mr. Earnshaw’s partiality towards Heathcliff exacerbates this animosity, undermining his authority and giving rise to a power struggle that persists even after his death. Earnshaw’s inability to foresee the division this favoritism causes ultimately leads to a cycle of revenge and cruelty within the family, perpetuated primarily by Heathcliff’s actions in response to his treatment by Hindley and others.

Impact on the Earnshaw Children

Mr. Earnshaw’s influence significantly shapes the personalities and fates of his children, Catherine and Hindley. His death leaves them in a vulnerable position, especially as Hindley ascends to the patriarchal role, asserting his power and seeking reprisal against Heathcliff for past grievances. Meanwhile, Catherine’s complex relationship with Heathcliff evolves amid these familial tensions, contributing to her character’s development and pivotal decisions. The dynamics that Mr. Earnshaw set in motion affect not only Catherine and Hindley but also the next generation of Earnshaws, including Hareton, whose life paths are steered by the earlier actions of their progenitor.

2. The Legacy of Mr. Earnshaw in the Narrative

Mr. Earnshaw’s role establishes foundational themes and sets in motion the events that shape the lives of the characters, particularly his children, Catherine and Hindley Earnshaw.

Themes of Love and Revenge

Mr. Earnshaw’s genuine affection for Heathcliff creates a sharp contrast with Hindley’s animosity, highlighting the novel’s central themes of love and revenge. Catherine Earnshaw and Heathcliff develop a profound bond, influenced by their shared childhood experiences and deep emotional connection, beyond Mr. Earnshaw’s acceptance of Heathcliff. But this love is twisted into a desire for revenge – especially after Mr. Earnshaw’s demise – as Hindley feels usurped and begins to mistreat Heathcliff, further fueling the cycle of revenge that propels the narrative.

Mr. Earnshaw’s Death and Its Consequences

His death brings substantial changes to Wuthering Heights and significantly impacts the plot. Following Mr. Earnshaw’s passing, Hindley inherits the estate and exerts his power to degrade Heathcliff’s status, altering relationships and escalating conflict. Frances, Hindley’s wife, indirectly contributes to the bitterness by supporting Hindley’s actions. This change in household dynamics leads Heathcliff to seek retribution, which reverberates through the lives of the other characters like Edgar and Isabella Linton, and later, Cathy Linton and Hareton Earnshaw.

Symbolism and References in Later Events

Mr. Earnshaw’s actions and decisions symbolize the broader societal conflicts, including the rigid social ambitions and conventions of the time. His favoritism towards Heathcliff over his biological son Hindley clashes with the era’s social norms. This conflict between personal affection and societal expectations creates a foil for Edgar and Isabella Linton’s more conventional behaviors. Nelly Dean, the narrator, often references Mr. Earnshaw’s traits in the younger characters, indicating his lasting influence on the family’s legacy intertwined with the ongoing violence and conflict.