Hindley Earnshaw in Wuthering Heights

Hindley Earnshaw is a character from the classic novel Wuthering Heights, written by Emily Brontë and first published in 1847. As the son of Mr. Earnshaw and the brother of Catherine, Hindley is shaped by his upbringing at the Earnshaw family home, also named Wuthering Heights. The novel depicts him primarily through his complex relationships within the family, especially in contrast to Heathcliff, an orphan Mr. Earnshaw brings into the household. Hindley’s character trajectory is marked by loss, resentment, and eventual self-destruction, themes that are pivotal to the novel’s exploration of the darker aspects of human nature and society.

Emily Brontë’s portrayal of Hindley Earnshaw offers a study of the destructive power of jealousy and the repercussions of favoritism. Hindley’s hostility toward Heathcliff is evident from the latter’s arrival, setting the stage for their lifelong conflict. This enmity sets in motion a variety of conflicts that resonate throughout the generations depicted in Wuthering Heights. Brontë utilizes Hindley’s decline from a privileged son to a figure consumed by bitterness to scrutinize the rigid social structures and personal vendettas that can dominate rural English life.

Within Wuthering Heights, Hindley’s impact extends beyond his own life, influencing the fates of other characters and contributing to the novel’s overarching examination of human passion and its consequences. His interactions and the subsequent effects on Heathcliff and others around him serve to illustrate the cyclical nature of revenge and the inheritance of emotional turmoil. Through Hindley’s story arc, Emily Brontë critiques not only the societal norms of her time but also the complex interplay between individual actions and societal influences, underscoring how inherited status and wealth are not immune to a fall from grace when intertwined with the emotional landscape of a turbulent home.

Recommended: Read Wuthering Heights at PageVio

1. Hindley Earnshaw Character Analysis

Hindley Earnshaw is a complex character in Wuthering Heights. His relationships with family members and Heathcliff shape much of the novel’s drama and tragedy.

Family Origins and Childhood

Born to Mr. and Mrs. Earnshaw, Hindley is raised at Wuthering Heights, a remote farmhouse on the moors of Yorkshire. He is the eldest son and brother of Catherine Earnshaw, and his expectation to inherit Wuthering Heights is a matter of family tradition and hierarchy.

• Mr. Earnshaw: Hindley’s father and head of the Earnshaw family.
• Mrs. Earnshaw: His mother, who passed away when Hindley is quite young.
• Catherine Earnshaw: His spirited and wild younger sister.

Relationship with Mr. Earnshaw

Hindley is the favored child by being the eldest son. However, his relationship with his father becomes strained after the arrival of Heathcliff.

• Pre-Heathcliff Era: Hindley is positioned as the heir to Wuthering Heights.
• Post-Heathcliff Era: Mr. Earnshaw’s attention shifts to Heathcliff, fueling Hindley’s resentment.

Interactions with Heathcliff

Heathcliff’s arrival at Wuthering Heights significantly alters Hindley’s life. Hindley’s animosity toward the orphan, Heathcliff, is evident from childhood and grows over time.

• Childhood: Hindley torments Heathcliff, often cruelly so, setting the stage for a lifelong feud.
• Adulthood: Upon Mr. Earnshaw’s death, Hindley inherits Wuthering Heights and reduces Heathcliff to the status of a servant, further deepening the chasm between them.
• Impact on Hindley: His consistent cruelty toward Heathcliff reveals his flaws and contributes to his ultimate downfall.

2. Adult Life and Conduct

Hindley Earnshaw’s adult life was marked by personal tumult, self-destructive behavior, and a cycle of animosity and retribution that had lasting effects on those around him.

Marriage and Issues with Frances

Hindley’s marriage to Frances was one of the few sources of happiness in his adult life, though it was short-lived due to her premature death. Frances’s passing plunged Hindley into deep misery and exacerbated his tendencies towards dissipation.

• Marriage: A source of brief contentment
• Death of Frances: Trigger for further decline

Descent into Dissipation

After the death of his wife, Hindley fell into a steep decline characterized by drunkenness, gambling, and general depravity. His self-indulgence led to a significant deterioration in his character and judgment, affecting his responsibilities, including the care of his son, Hareton.

• Drunkenness & Gambling: Frequent and severe
• Depravity: Evident in personal neglect and poor judgment

Conflict and Revenge

Hindley’s cruelty and anger often manifested in violence and abuse, particularly toward Heathcliff, whom he despised. His quest for revenge was a broader expression of his bitterness and resentment towards life’s circumstances, creating an atmosphere of fear and oppression within Wuthering Heights. This tyrannical behavior affected not only Heathcliff but also his own son, Hareton, whom he neglected and mistreated.

• Cruelty & Anger: Directed towards Heathcliff and others
• Violence & Abuse: Intensified by his need for revenge and personal bitterness

3. Impact on Wuthering Heights

Hindley Earnshaw’s mismanagement and personal vices lead to significant changes at Wuthering Heights.

Financial and Social Decline

As the head of Wuthering Heights, Hindley Earnshaw’s fiscal irresponsibility drastically alters the estate’s fortune. He gambles away its resources and accrues debts. His descent into alcoholism further exacerbates these issues, starkly contrasting the Earnshaws’ former stability. The magnitude of Hindley’s financial problems becomes evident when he takes out a mortgage on Wuthering Heights, securing the property’s fate and his family’s social standing.

• Estate Mortgage: Hindley mortgages Wuthering Heights.
• Excessive Spending: He expends resources, leading to financial ruin.
• Neglect of Responsibilities: Hindley neglects the estate, affecting the quality of life for servants like Joseph and Nelly Dean.
• Alcoholic Deterioration: His alcoholism contributes to the decline and disrepair of the property.

Relationship with Other Characters

Hindley’s relationships with other characters deeply impact the social dynamics at Wuthering Heights and the neighboring Thrushcross Grange. His enmity towards Heathcliff, whom his father Mr. Earnshaw favored, leads Hindley to cruelly reduce Heathcliff to a servant upon his inheritance of the estate.

• Hindley vs. Heathcliff: Hindley demotes Heathcliff, undermining the latter’s status and igniting a lifelong grudge.
• Effects on Catherine Earnshaw: Hindley’s actions indirectly influence Catherine’s relationship with Heathcliff and contribute to the complexities of her eventual marriage into the Linton family.
• Impacts on Hareton Earnshaw: His son, Hareton, suffers from Hindley’s negligence, missing out on proper education and upbringing.
• Dynamic with the Lintons: The contrast between the declining Earnshaws and the more stable Lintons highlights the changing fortunes of the two families.

Across interactions with characters like Zillah and others, Hindley’s troubled leadership of Wuthering Heights casts long shadows on the estate’s legacy and the intertwined fates of the families within.

4. Literary Analysis and Interpretation

In exploring Hindley Earnshaw’s character, this section delves into his pivotal role in Wuthering Heights and the themes his presence underlines.

Hindley’s Role in the Narrative

Hindley Earnshaw serves as a crucial antagonist in Wuthering Heights. His role is multifaceted: he initially stands as the legitimate heir to Wuthering Heights and later embodies the bitterness of a man consumed by loss and vengeance. His descent into destructiveness significantly impacts the novel’s progression and the fate of other characters, extending beyond his mistreatment of Heathcliff to affect characters like Hareton and contribute to the overall atmosphere of decay and ruin.

• Inheritance: Hindley’s inheritance of Wuthering Heights upon Mr. Earnshaw’s death sets a critical plot in motion.
• Treatment of Heathcliff: Hindley’s cruel mistreatment of Heathcliff propels the latter’s quest for vengeance and reflects Hindley’s internal turmoil.

Themes and Symbolism

The role of Hindley Earnshaw is emblematic of several key themes in Gothic literature, particularly those related to decline, revenge, and the cyclical nature of suffering.

• Vengeance: Hindley is both a victim and perpetrator of vengeance, illustrating the blurred boundaries between the two in Gothic fiction.
• Decay and Ruin: Hindley’s deterioration mirrors the Gothic fascination with decline, both physically and morally.

Critical Analysis

Hindley’s character has been analyzed by scholars in the context of the novel’s themes and narrative structure. His journey from privileged son to embittered adversary encapsulates the novel’s exploration of the consequences of revenge and the persistence of inherent cruelty.

• Quotes: Hindley’s dialogue provides insight into his motivations and emotions, conveying his character with stark clarity.
• Description: Brontë’s vivid description of Hindley’s erratic behavior and downfall contributes to the dark, brooding atmosphere characteristic of Gothic fiction.