Frances Earnshaw in Wuthering Heights

Frances Earnshaw is a lesser known but impactful character in the classic novel Wuthering Heights by Emily Brontë. Though her presence in the novel is brief, Frances plays a significant role in the lives of other characters, particularly her husband Hindley Earnshaw. Her influence extends beyond her life, affecting Hindley’s behavior and the atmosphere at Wuthering Heights, thereby shaping the experiences and futures of the other characters in the story.

Frances Earnshaw is introduced as Hindley’s wife upon his return to Wuthering Heights. Her character is portrayed as gentle and slightly naive, a stark contrast to the rough and brooding nature of the Earnshaw family estate.

Through her relationship with Hindley, Frances indirectly contributes to a chain of events that intensifies the drama at Wuthering Heights. Her death from consumption (tuberculosis) marks a turning point in Hindley’s life, leading him to further descent into alcoholism and cruelty. Despite her short life and the little direct action she takes within the narrative, Frances’s impact is felt long after she departs from the story. Her character serves as a vehicle for exploring themes of love, loss, suffering, and the far-reaching consequences of these experiences.

Recommended: Read Wuthering Heights at PageVio

1. Frances Earnshaw Character Analysis

Frances Earnshaw is a pivotal yet often overlooked character in Wuthering Heights, whose relationships and social interactions significantly impact the narrative and development of other characters.

Frances and Hindley Earnshaw

Frances Earnshaw, after marrying Hindley Earnshaw, becomes a central figure in his life. Their relationship sees Hindley’s character begin to decline, a process that is exacerbated after Frances dies from tuberculosis, then referred to as consumption. Her death leaves Hindley to drown his sorrows in alcohol, further intensifying his abusive behavior toward Heathcliff. However, it’s important to note that Hindley’s descent into cruelty predates Frances’ death, and her direct influence on his transformation is not as pronounced as it may seem.

Frances’ Impact on Hareton

Frances’ untimely death from consumption significantly affects Hareton Earnshaw‘s upbringing. Although her role as a mother is short-lived, her absence leads to a lack of parenting and education for Hareton, as a grief-stricken Hindley neglects his fatherly duties. Consequently, Hareton grows up uneducated and uncultured, mirroring Heathcliff’s degraded status when he first arrived at Wuthering Heights.

Interactions with Other Characters

Frances interacts sparingly with other characters, but her presence affects their dynamics, particularly with Catherine Earnshaw and Nelly Dean. Her marriage to Hindley disrupts the relationships within the Earnshaw family, further complicating Heathcliff’s quest for revenge and his tumultuous relationship with Catherine. Frances’ illness and death also leave a lasting imprint on the various households, illustrating the fragility of life in the harsh Yorkshire moors.

Frances in the Social Context

Within the social context of Yorkshire during the period of Wuthering Heights, Frances represents the potential for upward social mobility through marriage. However, the novel does not provide much detail about her style of dress or demeanor. Additionally, while her absence contributes to the degradation of social norms at Wuthering Heights, this decline is more directly attributed to Hindley’s and later Heathcliff’s actions rather than Frances’ absence alone.

2. Themes and Literary Significance

In exploring Frances Earnshaw’s role, the themes of love and revenge, class and morality, and disease and suffering stand out, each adding depth and complexity to the narrative crafted by Emily Brontë.

Frances and the Theme of Love and Revenge

Frances Earnshaw, though not the primary focus in Wuthering Heights, plays a pivotal role in the unfolding of love and revenge narratives. Love, as a driving force, manifests in her marriage to Hindley, yet this bond also indirectly contributes to Hindley’s descent into revenge against Heathcliff. Frances’s relationship illustrates how romantic entanglements can be intertwined with cycles of vengeance, which is a core element in the destructive journey of other central characters like Heathcliff and Catherine. However, it’s important to note that Frances’ direct influence on Hindley’s revenge is more subtle, as his behavior is primarily driven by his character and circumstances.

Social Class and Morality

Frances is indicative of how social class shapes the characters’ lives in Wuthering Heights. Her marriage to Hindley is seen as a slight elevation in her social status, yet class divisions remain predominant and affect individual moral compasses. The way Frances navigates her new social role, and its impact on her siblings, presents a microcosm of the broader class struggles depicted by Emily Brontë, where societal expectations often clash with personal desires and morality.

Disease and Suffering

The theme of suffering through disease is exemplified by Frances’s battle with consumption (tuberculosis), a common ailment of the era. Her illness and subsequent death deeply affect her family, particularly her husband and child, highlighting the pervasive nature of suffering. Brontë utilizes Frances’s ailment to underline the frailty of life and the indiscriminate nature of disease, irrespective of an individual’s class or social status. While the novel does not explicitly explore the intersection of beauty, suffering, and the ephemerality of life through Frances’ character, her decline due to consumption is a poignant reminder of these themes that are widely explored in the literary studies of the novel.